Wind attacks edges and ridges
Uplift concentrates at rakes, eaves, ridges, and hips — the places where the covering has an edge to catch. Damage found only in the middle of a slope after a wind event deserves a question about what caused it.
Document immediately
Photograph displaced tile, lifted shingles, debris in the yard, and any interior evidence the same day, with dates. Post-event photos taken before anyone climbs up are the most credible record you will have.
Repair scale versus replacement scale
A dozen displaced tiles and some lifted ridge cap is repair work. A blanket replacement recommendation after a wind event should be tied to documented damage across the roof, not to a general statement about the roof's age.
Be careful with door-knock inspections
Some are legitimate. Ask for identification and a licence number, be present for the inspection, and insist photos include context that identifies your roof rather than an anonymous close-up.
Frankly